Pipe failure prediction and impacts assessment in a water distribution network

Abstract Water distribution networks (WDNs) aim to provide water with desirable quantity, quality and pressure to the consumers. However, in case of pipe failure, which is the cumulative effect of physical, operational and weather-related factors, the WDN might fail to meet these objectives. Rehabilitation and replacement of some components of WDNs, such as pipes, is a common practice to improve the condition of the network to provide an acceptable level of service. The overall aim of this thesis is to predict—long-term, annually and short-term—the pipe failure propensity and assess the impacts of a single pipe failure on the level of service. The long-term and annual predictions facilitate the need for effective capital investment, whereas the short-term predictions have an operational use, enabling the water utilities to adjust the daily allocation and planning of resources to accommodate possible increase in pipe failure. The proposed methodology was implemented to the cast iron (CI) pipes in a UK WDN. The long-term and annual predictions are made using a novel combination of Evolutionary Polynomial Regression (EPR) and K-means clustering. The inclusion of K-means improves the predictions’ accuracy by using a set of models instead of a single model. The long-term predictive models consider physical factors, while the annual predictions also include weather-related factors. The analysis is conducted on a group level assuming that pipes with similar properties have similar breakage patterns. Soil type is another aggregation criterion since soil properties are associated with the corrosion of metallic pipes. The short-term predictions are based on a novel Artificial Neural Network (ANN) model that predicts the variations above a predefined threshold in the number of failures in the following days. The ANN model uses only existing weather data to make predictions reducing their uncertainty. The cross-validation technique is used to derive an accurate estimate of accuracy of EPR and ANN models by guaranteeing that all observations are used for both training and testing, and each observation is used for testing only once. The impact of pipe failure is assessed considering its duration, the topology of the network, the geographic location of the failed pipe and the time. The performance indicators used are the ratio of unsupplied demand and the number of customers with partial or no supply. Two scenarios are examined assuming that the failure occurs when there is a peak in either pressure or demand. The pressure-deficient conditions are simulated by introducing a sequence of artificial elements to all the demand nodes with pressure less than the required. This thesis proposes a new combination of a group-based method for deriving the failure rate and an individual-pipe method for evaluating the impacts on the level of service. Their conjunction indicates the most critical pipes. The long-term approach improves the accuracy of predictions, particularly for the groups with very low or very high failure frequency, considering diameter, age and length. The annual predictions accurately predict the fluctuation of failure frequency and its peak during the examined period. The EPR models indicate a strong direct relationship between low temperatures and failure frequency. The short-term predictions interpret the intra-year variation of failure frequency, with most failures occurring during the coldest months. The exhaustive trials led to the conclusion that the use of four consecutive days as input and the following two days as output results in the highest accuracy. The analysis of the relative significance of each input variable indicates that the variables that capture the intensity of low temperatures are the most influential. The outputs of the impact assessment indicate that the failure of most of the pipes in both scenarios (i.e. peak in pressure and demand) would have low impacts (i.e. low ratio of unsupplied demand and small number of affected nodes). This can be explained by the fact that the examined network is a large real-life network, and a single failure of a distribution pipe is likely to cause pressure-deficient conditions in a small part of it, whereas performance elsewhere is mostly satisfactory. Furthermore, the complex structure of the WDN allows them to recover from local pipe failures, exploiting the topological redundancy provided by closed loops, so that the flow could reach a given demand node through alternative paths

Pipeline failure prediction in water distribution networks using weather conditions as explanatory factors

This is the author accepted manuscript. The final version is available from IWA Publishing via the DOI in this recordThis paper examines the impact of weather conditions on pipe failure in water distribution networks using artificial neural network (ANN) and evolutionary polynomial regression (EPR). A number of weather-related factors over 4 consecutive days are the input of the binary ANN model while the output is the occurrence or not of at least a failure during the following 2 days. The model is able to correctly distinguish the majority (87%) of the days with failure(s). The EPR is employed to predict the annual number of failures. Initially, the network is divided into six clusters based on pipe diameter and age. The last year of the monitoring period is used for testing while the remaining years since the beginning are retained for model development. An EPR model is developed for each cluster based on the relevant training data. The results indicate a strong relationship between the annual number of failures and frequency and intensity of low temperatures. The outputs from the EPR models are used to calculate the failures of the homogenous groups within each cluster proportionally to their length.The work reported is supported by the UK Engineering & Physical Sciences Research Council (EPSRC) project Safe & SuRe (EP/K006924/1)

Pipeline failure prediction in water distribution networks using evolutionary polynomial regression combined with Κ- means clustering

This is the author accepted manuscript. The final version is available from Taylor & Francis via the DOI in this record.This paper presents a new approach for improving pipeline failure predictions by combining a data driven statistical model, i.e. Evolutionary Polynomial Regression (EPR), with K-means clustering. The EPR is used for prediction of pipe failures based on length, diameter and age of pipes as explanatory factors. Individual pipes are aggregated using their attributes of age, diameter and soil type to create homogenous groups of pipes. The created groups were divided into training and test datasets using the cross-validation technique for calibration and validation purposes respectively. The K-means clustering is employed to partition the training data into a number of clusters for individual EPR models. The proposed approach was demonstrated by application to the cast iron pipes of a water distribution network in the UK. Results show the proposed approach is able to significantly reduce the error of pipe failure predictions especially in the case of a large number of failures. The prediction models were used to calculate the failure rate of individual pipes for rehabilitation planning.The work reported is supported by the UK Engineering & Physical Sciences Research Council (EPSRC) project Safe &SuRe (EP/K006924/1)